Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain is one of the few players who can speak from first-hand experience about both Jurgen Klopp and Arsene Wenger after working under each manager at different stages of his career.
That is what makes his view worth listening to. Oxlade-Chamberlain saw Wenger at Arsenal and Klopp at Liverpool, which means he understands both the differences in style and the differences in feeling around them.
At the surface level, neither manager would be described as distant. In fact, they were beloved in their respective fanbases.
What is your all-time favourite Mohamed Salah moment at Liverpool? ⚽
But for Oxlade-Chamberlain, there was one clear detail that separated Klopp from Wenger — the fear factor.
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain says Klopp’s warmth came with an edge
Wenger could be calm, open and easy to approach, while Klopp often gave off that same warmth in public. The difference, in Oxlade-Chamberlain’s eyes, was what sat underneath it.
Comparing the two managers during an interview with All Out Football, he explained: “I think a bit of fear factor. I think that was the biggest thing that I saw as a difference with Arsene. Arsene is very approachable.
“And as approachable as Jurgen is, there’s always that fear factor. If I don’t run one time, I’m going to hear about it and I’m really going to hear about it. So you just don’t ever want to take that risk.”
That sums Klopp up perfectly. Players felt his support, but they also knew the standards were absolute, and that edge is a huge contributor to the success that made him such an icon at Anfield.
Wenger and Klopp changed English football in very different ways
That contrast also fits the wider picture of both men. Wenger often came across as more cerebral and aesthetic, while Klopp built his teams around emotion, intensity and collective belief.
Oxlade-Chamberlain’s comment lands because it gives a player’s view of the same divide. Klopp was approachable, but he also made sure nobody in his dressing room forgot what was demanded of them.
Do you think Jurgen Klopp will re-join Liverpool?
That is why Liverpool supporters connected with him so deeply.
He was never just a charismatic figure on the touchline, he was the manager who made intensity feel non-negotiable. The kind of instensity we have struggled to rediscover under Arne Slot.
Receive a digest of our best Liverpool content each week direct to your mailbox
