Xabi Alonso is the obvious choice for Liverpool if Arne Slot leaves. Liverpool supporters are not in the mood for another gamble.
After a disappointing 2025/26 campaign, the next managerial appointment would carry huge weight at Anfield. This is not the kind of summer where fans will patiently accept a long-term project dressed up as a rebuild. Liverpool would need a figure capable of lifting standards immediately, restoring belief quickly and handling the pressure that comes with one of the biggest jobs in football.
Sebastian Hoeness has done impressive work at VfB Stuttgart and deserves respect for that. But if the Reds are forced into replacing Arne Slot, this is the moment to go for the bigger, proven name: Xabi Alonso.
Just how bad do you want Arne Slot gone? 😬
Liverpool need a manager who can deliver straight away
That is where Alonso, who has been called the ‘obvious fit’ to replace Slot by Pete O’Rourke when discussing Hoeness as an option, stands apart.
Liverpool’s next boss would walk into a situation where excuses would be in short supply. Supporters would expect a response from day one, not in 18 months. They would want a manager with the authority to command the dressing room instantly, the tactical reputation to improve results quickly, and the personality to cope with the scrutiny that comes with every defeat, substitution and press conference.
Alonso has already shown he can handle that kind of spotlight. His rise has not been quiet or niche, it has been one of the most high-profile managerial ascents in Europe. That matters. Liverpool are not appointing for potential alone; they would be appointing for impact.
Hoeness may yet prove he belongs at elite level, but there is still a difference between impressing and convincing. The Merseyside faithful would need more than promise after a poor season. They would need someone who already looks like a manager built for the biggest stage.
Just how bad do you want Arne Slot gone? 😬
Alonso’s Liverpool bond could matter more than ever
There is another factor Liverpool cannot ignore: trust.
Alonso would not just arrive with a reputation. He would arrive with a connection to the club, the city and the supporters. That emotional credit matters, especially if results do not immediately turn. Fans are far more likely to stay with a manager they feel understands the club and what it demands.
That does not mean the Spaniard, who continues to be linked with Liverpool, would get a free pass. But he would get more faith in difficult moments than an outsider. At a club where atmosphere and unity can shape a season, that is a major advantage.
And that is the key point. The Reds do not just need the best coach available, they need the appointment that supporters are most likely to believe in. Right now, that looks like Alonso by a distance.
Receive a digest of our best Liverpool content each week direct to your mailbox
