Yesterday, Liverpool lost 4-3 to Bournemouth and, in typical fashion, supporters were quick to find one or two scapegoats to blame the entire loss on.

Liverpool were 3-1 up after 65 minutes and, despite spirited play from Bournemouth, few fans would have expected the inspired fightback that would ensue.

When things go well for Liverpool, supporters are quick to praise the team as a collective and maybe select one or two players as deserving of extra credit. When the Reds lose, however, it’s inevitable that there will be a scapegoat. An easy target after Liverpool’s appalling bottle-job yesterday was new signing Loris Karius.

Since joining from Mainz, Karius has had a difficult time of settling into the league and finding his feet. The German keeper missed the start of the season as a result of a broken hand and when he did return to the starting lineup, he didn’t impress a whole lot.

Karius’ uninspiring performances for Liverpool meant that he had a lot to do before being labelled a success and yesterday’s display at the Vitality Stadium didn’t help. In all fairness, Karius was very poor and at fault for the last goal, but calls for the ‘keeper to get the sack are unwarranted and an indictment on the desire from modern football fans for instantaneous success.

And then you’ve got those who would rather see him leave the club…


Is the criticism justified?

Of course, it is. Loris Karius was simply not good enough against Bournemouth and for most part of his Liverpool career so far and supporters are justified in feeling angry by lost points as a result of another dodgy ‘keeper.

BUT, and this is a huge but, there is no justification for claims that Karius should get dropped or sold. Yes, he’s had a difficult time adjusting to the rigours of the Premier League, but many have forgotten the saves he’s made like against Sunderland last week.

Klopp responded to Karius’ critics yesterday, Jamie Carragher included, and many fans could take a leaf out of the German coach’s book.

“In eight starts for Liverpool he has not shown me one thing to suggest he’s good enough at this level,” Carragher said, according to the Guardian. “He’s yet to convince me in any game. It is still early days but he would need a massive improvement. When your defence is under pressure, sometimes you need your goalkeeper to save it and he’s miles away [from Fraser’s second goal].

“Too often in last two or three years, Liverpool fall apart when put under pressure. The back four and the goalkeeper can’t deal with [pressure].”

Klopp said: “Look, I’m sure people criticised Jamie Carragher in his career. I have no concerns [with Karius]. If you make mistakes, you get criticised. That’s what happens in life, so I have no problem with that. So if people want to say we’re blind, silly, not good enough, then do it. We missed chances today but do we have good strikers? Yes, we do. And the last goal was not easy for a goalkeeper. It says nothing about him as a goalkeeper. It happens.

Klopp’s intent is to downplay the situation, and rightly so, but there is some merit in what Carragher had to say. At the end of the day, Karius is young and clearly needs time to adjust, but calls for his head are a long way off the mark.

Michael Mongie
Just like you, I am a hugely passionate Liverpool supporter. I started Rousing the Kop in January 2015 and since then it has grown tremendously and has even been nominated as 'Best New Football Blog' in the Football Blogging Awards.


  1. Oh come on! It was down to Klopp as soon as the team sheet saw Lucas in the back four where we already have an ageing Milner. If ever there was a line-up that would guarantee tired legs and ‘square pegs’ this was it. The outcome was inevitable.

  2. Why can’t we find another Ray Clemence? We never worried when the ball went near him as he was dependable and probably made 2 mistakes in the years we had him.
    Karius is as bad as Mignolet when it comes to the high ball and neither gives me any confidence when the ball is hoofed towards the six-yard box.
    Having 2 dodgy keepers is simply not good enough and swapping one for the other every couple of games, when the incumbent keeper makes a hash of something, is only replacing one iffy keeper with another.
    I’m sick and tired of fearing the worst every time a ball is crossed into Liverpool’s area . . .
    As for the defence . . . useless. Milner is not a LB, Lucas is not a CB unless you are playing somebody from the lower leagues in a cup competition at Anfield and Lovren is not a defender worthy of a place at LFC.
    A woeful performance by just about everybody with nobody seemingly interested in the second half.